A prairie trail stretching toward the horizon

iRoth4U / THE PREMIUM BILL NOBODY WARNED ME ABOUT

“Medicare was hitting me for over $700 a month because of my income.”

That is not a penalty for earning too much to qualify. It is a surcharge called IRMAA, and it is set from a tax return you filed two years ago — which means the income that caused it may already be gone.

Educational content, not personalized tax or benefits advice. Bracket amounts are the published 2026 figures and change every year.

SEE THE NUMBER. THEN DECIDE WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT.

Where does your income land?

Enter the modified adjusted gross income from your 2024 return — adjusted gross income plus tax-exempt interest. The estimate shows the 2026 premium that follows from it.

If you filed jointly, enter the household figure. Nothing here is saved after you leave the page.

Filing status on that return

Your 2026 Part B premium

$284.10

Surcharge tier
Tier 1
Added to your drug plan
$14.50/mo
Extra over the standard premium
$95.70/mo
Extra over a full year
$1,148.40/yr
To drop one tier, MAGI must be at or under
$109,000
Room before the next tier up
$17,000

The drug-plan figure is added on top of whatever your plan already charges. Social Security usually withholds both from your benefit check. Your actual bill can differ — the letter from Social Security is the authority.

HOW THE SURCHARGE WORKS

Four things about IRMAA that surprise people.

Taxable withdrawals are the usual trigger.

Traditional 401(k) and traditional IRA withdrawals land in adjusted gross income. So do Roth IRA conversions, since a conversion is a taxable event in the year you make it. A bridge drawn from pre-tax money is income Medicare will look at later.

The bill arrives two years late.

Premiums for a given year are set from the tax return filed two years earlier. Income you report in 2024 shapes premiums billed in 2026. By the time the letter arrives, the income that caused it is already history.

It is a cliff, not a slope.

One dollar over a bracket line moves you to the next tier for the whole year. That is why a single large conversion, a bonus, or a big withdrawal can cost far more than the tax on it suggests.

Roth money is the one that stays quiet.

Qualified Roth IRA withdrawals are not taxable, so they do not raise MAGI and do not push you into a surcharge. That difference is a large part of why Dan is moving his thinking toward Roth.

THE 2026 BRACKETS

The lines Medicare draws through your income.

Determined from your 2024 return. CMS publishes new amounts each November, so confirm the current year before you plan against these.

Up to and including $109,000

Part B
$202.90
Drug plan
None
Extra
None

More than $109,000 and up to $137,000

Part B
$284.10
Drug plan
$14.50/mo
Extra
$95.70/mo

More than $137,000 and up to $171,000

Part B
$405.80
Drug plan
$37.50/mo
Extra
$240.40/mo

More than $171,000 and up to $205,000

Part B
$527.50
Drug plan
$60.40/mo
Extra
$385.00/mo

More than $205,000 and under $500,000

Part B
$649.20
Drug plan
$83.30/mo
Extra
$529.60/mo

$500,000 and above

Part B
$689.90
Drug plan
$91.00/mo
Extra
$578.00/mo

Married people who file separately and lived together during the tax year get a compressed table of their own — the deep tiers start at the same line as an individual return. Social Security applies that reading by default when the IRS reports the status as married filing separately.

WHAT COUNTS AND WHAT DOES NOT

MAGI is wider than your tax bill.

Raises MAGI

  • Wages and self-employment

    Paychecks, bonuses, and net rideshare or side-business earnings all count.

  • Traditional 401(k) and IRA withdrawals

    Every taxable dollar of pre-tax retirement money you take out counts as income.

  • Roth IRA conversions

    Converting pre-tax money into a Roth is taxable income in the year you convert.

  • Capital gains and dividends

    Selling investments to live on adds to the income Medicare reads two years later.

  • Tax-exempt interest

    Municipal bond interest is not in taxable income, but it is added back into MAGI.

  • Pension payments

    Taxable pension income counts toward MAGI — even though it does not count as work earnings for Social Security.

Does not raise MAGI

  • Qualified Roth IRA withdrawals

    Tax-free Roth withdrawals are not taxable income, so they do not raise MAGI.

  • Roth IRA contributions

    Contributions are made with after-tax money and never reduce MAGI — but they do not add to it either.

  • Gifts and inheritances

    Money you receive rather than earn generally does not enter MAGI, though income it later produces can.

  • Life-changing event income

    A drop in income after the tax year can be reported to Social Security on its own, using a more recent figure.

One distinction trips people up: the same dollar of pension or 401(k) money does not count as work earnings for Social Security’s earnings test, yet it does count toward MAGI for Medicare. Earning too much for a direct Roth contribution and paying a surcharge on the same return are two different rules reading the same income.

IF YOUR INCOME HAS DROPPED SINCE THEN

You can ask them to look again.

Social Security will use a more recent income figure if something in your life changed the money coming in. Retirement counts — stopping work or cutting hours is on the list. Bring documentation: a letter from your employer, a signed copy of the return for the year in question, or something similar.

  • You or your spouse stopped working or reduced your work hours
  • You married or divorced, or your spouse died
  • You or your spouse lost income-producing property because of a disaster or other event beyond your control
  • You or your spouse experienced a scheduled cessation, termination, or reorganization of an employer’s pension plan
  • You or your spouse received a settlement from an employer or former employer because of the employer’s closure, bankruptcy, or reorganization

A new decision, not an appeal

For a life-changing event you file Form SSA-44 to report the change. If your income has gone down, this is usually the faster path — and you do not need to file a separate appeal to use it.

SSA: ask for a reduction

If the numbers themselves are wrong

When the determination rests on incorrect or outdated IRS data — an amended return, a return Social Security never received — you can appeal the decision and request reconsideration. That is a different process from reporting a life-changing event.

SSA: how the determination works

A reduction granted after a life-changing event applies going forward and can cover the current year’s premiums. It does not undo a one-time income spike in the return itself — that is a planning problem, not an appeals problem.

DAN’S CASE STUDY · GET WHAT’S YOURS

One trip to the Social Security office. The $700 surcharge went away.

  1. 1. The hit. While Dan was still working, Medicare was charging him over $700 a month — set by an old tax return from his high-earning sheet-metal years.
  2. 2. The change. He retired July 1, 2026. His 401(k) draw started first, Social Security began around mid-August, and his pension started at the end of September — both paid back to July 1.
  3. 3. The proof. He took his pension paperwork to the Social Security office to show what his income would be now.
  4. 4. The letter. About a month later, a letter said he no longer owed the surcharge. His Medicare premium now comes straight out of his Social Security check.

The lesson: they won’t fix it for you

Social Security only knew Dan’s old income. Nobody calls you when you retire — you have to bring the proof. If you stopped work or your income dropped, report it with Form SSA-44 and your documents. Your result depends on your own income and paperwork.

A choice Dan made — know the rule first

Dan has no tax withheld from his Social Security or pension, so that money keeps earning until tax time. The catch: the IRS expects tax paid during the year. Too little withheld or paid in estimates can mean an underpayment penalty — and the full bill still comes due in April. Check the safe-harbor rules before copying this.

IRS: underpayment of estimated tax

WHAT THIS MEANS FOR A BRIDGE PLAN

The money you draw to live on has a delayed invoice.

Dan retired about eighteen months before his planned age-67 claim and let the 401(k) carry those months. The withdrawals were never a mystery — they were taxable income, and he had been pushing money into pre-tax accounts for years to lower his taxable income while his pay was high.

What he found out afterward is that the income figure on an old return — not the money he had now — was what set the premium. Taxable withdrawals are part of that income picture whenever they happen, which is why a bridge funded entirely from pre-tax money can carry a cost that shows up long after the bridge is crossed.

That is the reverse-engineering habit applied to a bill: see the premium you will be handed, work backward to the income year that produced it, and change the withdrawals before they happen — not after the letter arrives.

Questions to bring to a professional

  • Which years are already locked in? The return you have already filed decides a premium you have not seen yet.
  • Can the withdrawals be split across years? Because the tiers are cliffs, a smaller withdrawal in two years can cost less than one larger withdrawal in one.
  • Is there tax-free money to draw first? Qualified Roth withdrawals do not raise MAGI.
  • Does a life-changing event apply? Stopping work or cutting hours can justify a fresh determination.
  • What does the whole bill look like? Part B, the drug-plan surcharge, and any supplemental premium arrive as separate numbers.
TROUBLESHOOTING 101 / FURTHER RESEARCHCheck your sources first.Every link below opens in a new tab, so iRoth4U stays right here with you.

CMS publishes new amounts every November. Confirm the current premium year before you plan against these brackets.

BEFORE YOU BUY THE GEAR

Learn the trail. Then build the plan.

Read free Investing 101

An optional thank-you for the trail.

If you independently decide Robinhood is right for you, using our referral link is one way to say thank you for the free tools we’re building. Learning comes first. Opening an account is your choice.

Referral disclosure: Dan Johnson may receive a reward if you sign up through this link and meet Robinhood’s qualifying requirements. Any reward is subject to Robinhood’s current offer terms; no credit, stock, fractional share, or reward amount is guaranteed.

Visit Robinhood — referral link

You do not need to use this link, open an account, fund investments, or buy a subscription to access iRoth4U’s free tools or the linked learning articles. A Robinhood signup does not enroll you in an iRoth4U team. Education is not a recommendation to trade; investments can lose value.